May 27, 2020
I'm sorry that you didn't get the news you wanted from NYU. If you were to reapply Early Decision for next year, it is unlikely that anything would change. You really need to attend college elsewhere for at least a year, accumulate a strong academic record, and then apply as a transfer. The reason why I'm not optimistic about Early Decision is because, by the time your ED application is reviewed, you won't have yet received your first-semester grades from another college. Thus, the NYU admission folks will have little to go on other than the record they've already seen ... and rejected. However, if you apply REGULAR DECISION, as a transfer, they WILL be able to see what you've accomplished in the first semester at college.
As you'll see, here you can do a state-by-state search for colleges that are still accepting applications. Be careful to distinguish between available spaces for FRESHMEN (you) and for TRANSFERS ONLY.
Select your preferences in all the various categories ("Type of School," "Location," etc.) Then, at the end, under "Deadlines," be careful to mark, "Regular application deadline or priority date hasn't passed." When you hit "Results," you SHOULD get a list of colleges that will still welcome your application. If the list is too limited, try changing some of your preferences before you hit "Results" again.
Don't worry that the college you attend will not be nearly as selective as NYU. As long as you do VERY well there and also distinguish yourself in some way OUTSIDE of the classroom (e.g. leadership role, interesting hobby or sport, even paid employment), then you should be in the running as an NYU transfer.
Finally, OCCASIONALLY students who are denied admission at a favorite college are able to reapply and get in after completing a successful "Gap Year." In other words, they don't attend college at all or they may take an evening or online class while pursuing some other worthwhile program, project, or job.
However, in most cases, admission officials will NOT admit students who were initially denied without some proof of ACADEMIC achievement.
Thus I urge you to consider applying to college for this coming September, even though it's late. Alternatively you can find another productive way to spend the year ahead and then apply not only to NYU but also to OTHER colleges that might be good matches for you as well.