What Studies Show that Elite Colleges Are Worth the Cost?

Question: Can you direct me to any studies that support what I will call the “reputational difference” of attending an “elite” school. My son is applying to UPenn, Princeton, Stanford, WashU, Northwestern as well as a few smaller private institutions. The cost to attend these “elite” schools is $25K – $30K higher than these smaller schools. We are planning on helping him pay for his school, but not as much as the government or these schools expect us to. So he needs to make a decision to go to an “elite” school and graduate with over $100,000 in student loans, or go to a smaller private institution and graduate with $10,000 – $15,000 in loans. He is convinced it is worth the extra cost, I am not. I know these “elite” schools have no incentive to do such a study as there is no shortage of students and parents that seem to just accept it is worth the cost. Just hoping someone somewhere has done a study that can help him make his decision.

The Dale and Krueger study cited here is the most famous one: http://www.usnews.com/education/blogs/the-college-solution/2011/03/01/the-ivy-league-earnings-myth

But it doesn’t support the “reputational difference” of attending an elite school. To the contrary, it says that those who are qualified to attend a renowned college–but don’t–fare just as well in the earnings department as those who actually enrolled at one.

Yet, although I am always the first to wave warning flags when a family is about to take on considerable debt, I still believe that the “Should I spring for the pricey school?” question can only be answered with a resounding, “It depends.”

Factors such as a student’s family background (Ivy League? Blue collar?), a student’s career goals (investment banker? accountant? teacher?) and the student’s personality (Type A? Laid back?) as well as a look at the student’s overall college acceptance list and bottom-line costs would all go into the hopper before I would offer advice.

Hope that helps … and good luck with both the college decisions and your own.

(posted 11/30/2011)

The views and opinions expressed by those on this page, are those of the author or expert and do not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of Hobsons, College Confidential, or any of Hobsons entities or clients.